Mixed Emotions

  

by: grunmann

Tue Aug 17, 2010 at 21:46:02 PM EDT


( - promoted by Diane G)

There's an old, old, joke that goes "How would you define 'mixed emotions'?"  "That would be watching my mother-in-law drive my car off a cliff".

OK.  I think reading the following article is very apt to give you a case of mixed emotions.

grunmann :: Mixed Emotions
In terms of good health, one problem our society faces today - at least for an interim time period; I think this problem will take care of itself once the Great Collapse approaches cruising speed - is that of obesity.  

And that includes our young people.

Now guess what leading institution in the country today is truly concerned about overweight young people?

Here's a hint:  It's the same institution that sees global climate change as a long range security problem.

Linky goodness:

http://www.thesolutionsjournal...

Yup.  The U.S. military.  In a paper entitled "Too Fat to Fight", some 130 retired high ranking brass argue that junk foods be removed from schools, so that young people eat a more wholesome diet and avoid obesity problems.

Couple excerpts:

The study finds that an alarming 27 percent of all young Americans (ages 17-24) are simply too fat for military service. Between 1995 and 2008, 140,000 potential recruits failed their entrance physicals because they were overweight.
 

Now lest I be too cynical, the military has been a positive force for better nutrition in the past.  They were looking out for their own interests, of course, but still:

This is not the first time the military has weighed in on America's health. After finding that 40 percent of rejected recruits during World War II were suffering from malnutrition, the military was instrumental in the passage of the National School Lunch Program in 1946.

Sounds like socialism to me.  No wonder the Republicans thought George Marshall was a communist.

But you talk about "mixed emotions", for whom do you root in a situation like this?  I have no idea.

On the one hand, here we are in a state of perpetual war.  And perhaps the only way we ever break out of that situation is to raise a generation of blimps.  Maybe the only way to "give Peace a chance" is to tell the kids to pound down those Cheetos, Fritos, Suzy Qs, and wash 'em down with gallon after gallon of high fructose corn syrup.

On the other hand, that's a terrible way to raise food, it's non-sustainable for all the fertilizer you would have to use on the fields, it only encourages continuation of those absurd subsidies given to sugar and corn growers, it's bad for the planet, etc.  

But if you do promote a more healthful diet, and that results in lean, mean fighting machine young people who go around singing "over hill, over dale, as we hit the dusty trail, and I'll take the low road and jog to Baghdad a'fore ye..."  (I mixed a couple of songs there) what does that gain us if we have this Spartan like immense population that can be drawn on for cannon fodder as much as you like?

I just don't know.  Interesting battle of well-heeled institutions looming on the horizon.  You have the vastly popular military saying "slim the kids down" versus the corn and fast food lobby that worked hard and paid good $$$ (gosh darn it) to bribe the right people and get that junk stuff into the schools.  

What's a lobby grubbing, money taking Congress person supposed to do?

Well, that's why they take the big bucks they do to make the tough decisions like this.  

Tags: , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Mixed Emotions | 8 comments
Twinkies or Sparta? Thoughts/Comments? (11.00 / 2)


Probably Twinkies. (8.00 / 2)
Twinkies usually refrain from overacting.  You seldom hear a Twinkie say

"THIS IS CREAM FILLING!!!"


[ Parent ]
I hate (2.00 / 2)
when there is no discussion on my posts. I imagine you feel the same.

Right now, I can't even read you, though I know its good.

My husband's cancer prognosis came back not good - the worst possible scenario, truth be told.

Beyond that?

This blog is rife with great writers, and SUCKS in discussion, we all see that.

I have no idea how to change that.

But I read, and appreciate every word here.................  

Listen to The Wild Wild Left on internet talk radio



I'm so sorry to hear that, Diane. (5.00 / 1)
Bless you both.

[ Parent ]
Twinkies or Sparta? Shiiiiit (11.00 / 2)
This article hurt my brain, mostly because it reinforced my own pessimism about our country. Be fat or wage war? Fuck. That pretty much sums us up as a country.

But I think the military industrial complex just might be on the wane in America in the near future (by that I mean 40 years or so). If shit really gets bad -- like Ariana Huff's 'Third World America' highlights -- maybe we'll see a popular movement that just might knock a few percentage points out of our unnecessarily huge defense spending. Will that get us off the military industrial complex track? I doubt it. But it's a start.

As far as the fatties go...shiiiiit, there will NEVER be an uprising among the poor, working-class, and various other fucked over peoples in America as long as the vast majority of us have access to cheap fast food. I mean really, how effective can the far reaching call of class war be when nobody's starving because, shiiiiit, even poor folks can afford Big Macs?

Also, to Diane: I've had cancer issues in my family too. I sort of know the feeling (not that I've gone through what you're going through). Keep your head up, and I hope everything works out as best it can.  


Hey, Grunmann (10.00 / 2)
I took note of the same study and reacted exactly the same way......Ironic that the only jobs program we currently have in this country is the military.

Now I understand (12.00 / 3)
 I have to be brief b/c I am on a study break, but I wanted to mention something I have noticed lately. Will elaborate later & provide references if anyone is interested.

If you are a newly-minted behavioral science PhD at a major university, then you know you MUST demonstrate a successful record of obtaining external funding for your research if you want to have any hope of becoming tenured. Getting your research funded by the NIH (as opposed to most private foundations or organizations) is considered to be a prestigious accomplishment b/c it is extremely competitive. Securing NIH funding is basically required to get tenure at most large public research universities and snooty elite private universities.  Obtaining NIH funding generally says to the tenure review committee, "I was able to conceptualize and design a study that was so promising and sophisticated that I beat hordes of other scientists applying for this same grant".

However, I've recently noticed  a dramatic surge in the amount of funding the NIH gives to researchers studying interventions (e.g., public health interventions, psychological interventions, various psychosocial interventions) to prevent childhood obesity.  Childhood obesity seems to have become such a priority for the NIH that all a new assistant professor has to do is scrawl "I am gonna do some sort of study on fat kids or something if I can get around to it" on a napkin,  submit it to the NIH, and within days they have a million bucks in NIH funds for their research.  That is obviously an exaggeration, but not a very large one.

I never understood why all of a sudden we had an "obesity epidemic" among kids in the US (it certainly isn't a new phenomenon), and I thought it was strange that the NIH suddenly made this matter among its top priorities when considering the types of behavioral science grant proposals it would allocate $$ for.

Now it makes perfect sense.

I suspect the military is going to win this one, grunmann.

--

Just want to note along with D that I read the essays here whenever I get a chance.  I  do not comment very often these days due to time constraints...NOT a lack of interest. People who post here are IMO some of the best writers/ranters in the blogosphere, and I even appreciate the quality of the essays by those fp's with whom I may disagree strongly about certain matters. I respect good writing and/or solid argumentation for its own sake.

Ok, back to slaving away for the educational industrial complex. Yay.


Excellent insight, Elian - (11.00 / 2)
Thank you.


[ Parent ]
Mixed Emotions | 8 comments
Join Diane Gee on Wild Wild Left Radio 6pm ET Fridays!


Listen to The Wild Wild Left on internet talk radio

Latest Episode:



BEST OF WWL RADIO INTERVIEWS:

Bill Ayers

Noam Chomsky - #1

Noam Chomsky - #2

Ward Churchill - #1

Ward Churchull - #2

Bruce A Dixon

Norman Finkelstein

Frances Fox Piven

Peter Kornbluh

Prof. John Kozy - #1

Prof. John Kozy - #2

Joe Bageant - #1

Joe Bageant - #2 - RIP Joe!

Richard Gage AIA




Recent Comments













YOUR TOOLBOX

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Active Users
Currently 1 user(s) logged on.

Wild Info and Allies!


Diane Gee's Wild, Wild Left is a Multi-authored collaboration of the Best and the Brightest moving the World to a Sane & Equitable Future for the World! Join in!

 Subscribe in a reader


Community Guidelines

Links for the "Wildly Left" on Facebook

DONATIONS NOW TO KEEP WWL & WWL RADIO ALIVE!

DONATE
To support our efforts to be a Voice for the Left!!

*Neither WWL nor its proprietor, Diane G, are a registered charity: NO donations made to WWL or Diane G are tax deductible.

*****

Photobucket OWNING THE AIRWAVES ON FRIDAYS MIC CHECK: (Eastern times)

4pm - Here Be Monster's "Friday MIC Check"

5pm - Dusty's "What is Jerking my Chain This Week"

6pm - Our Very Own "WWL Radio Show"

7pm - "Progress Toward Democracy"

3am - "Up Late With Pinko the Bear"


Contributors' Blogs


Davidseth
- The Dream Antilles

Dusty
- Leftwing Nutjob

Edger
- Antemedius

Elian Maricon
- Queers Against Obama

Gentilly Girl:
- Gentilly Girl

Gwendolyn Holden Barry ~ and ~ Krell
- Roundtree 7

M_A:
- Militant Atheist

Michael Kwiatkowski:
- Progressive Independence

mishima
- Ignoring Asia

Nezua:
- The Unapologetic Mexican
- House of Nezua

Nonpartisan:
- The Crolian Progressive

Phil Rockstroh
- Ebullient Skepticism

Ria D
- firefly-dreaming


Search




Advanced Search


Noble Causes

Wild Wild Left Supports:



JVP Supports BDS to stop Human Rights Violations



Blogroll

*NEWS SOURCES*

- American Chronicle
- Carbon Trade Watch
- Center for Constitutional Rights
- Crooks & Liars
- Democracy Now!
- Democratic Underground
- FARK
- Huffington Post
- Information Clearing House
- Informed Comment ~ Juan Cole
- Just Foreign Policy
- Naomi Klein
- Newsroom-l.net
- News Hounds
- SALON: Glenn Greenwald
- Talking Points Memo
- TED: Technology, Entertainment, Design - The People's Voice
- The Nation

*REAL ISRAEL/PALESTINIAN NEWS SOURCES*

- Promised Land: news & opinion from Israel
- Haaretz
- Israel: The Only Democracy?
- Jewish Voice for Peace
- MuzzleWatch
- Palestinian Monitor

*LIBERALS WE LOVE*

- Antemedius
- Booman Tribune
- Break The Matrix (a new alliance of blogging)
- Cyrano's Journal Online
- Digby's
- Docudharma
- Edgeing
- Enigma Engine
- Fafblog!
- The Field Negro
- Firedoglake
- Happy Jihad's House of Pancakes
- Impeachment and Other Dreams
- Independent Bloggers Alliance
- Joe Bageant
- Lilith News
- My Sister Friends' House
- Native American Netroots
- NOBODY PASSES, Darling
- On the Homefront
- Once Upon a Time...
- Pam's House Blend
- Pretty Bird Woman House
- Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
- Speak Freely, Step Lively
- The Dream Antilles
- The Existentialist Cowboy
- The Fat Lady Sings
- The Tribesman
- Tom Dispatch
_ Ward Churchill Solidarity Network
_ Worldwide Sawdust
- XicanoPwr!!

*INTERNATIONAL EFFORTS*

- Intercontinental Cry
- Survival-International
- Amnesty International
- The First Post
- One News
- The Times of India
- RIA Novosti
- GBC
- The Daily Telegraph
- Uruknet
- MWC News
- Aljazeera
- Le Monde diplomatique
- Green Left
- The Independent
- CBC
- The Japan Times
- Prague Daily Monitor
- Scotsman
- Irish Independent News

*FREEDOM FROM RELIGION*

- Americans United for Separation of Church and State
- Atheist Revolution
- American Atheists
- American Humanist Association
- Atheist Alliance International
- Atheists for Human Rights
- Center for Inquiry
- Center for Naturalism
- Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster
- Coalition of Secular Voters
- Council for Secular Humanism
- Freedom From Religion Foundation
- Godless Americans
- Military Association of Atheists and Freethinkers
- National Center for Science Education
- Pharyngula
- Secular Coalition for America
- Secular Student Alliance

*ANTI-WAR, ANTI-TORTURE, HUMAN RIGHTS*

- Act Against Torture
- American Torture
- Amnesty International
- ACLU
- Cage Prisoners
- Human Rights First
- Human Rights Watch
- Iraq Body Count
- Iraq Coalition Casualties
- Iraq Moratorium
- Iraq Veterans Against the War
- No More Victims
- Physicians For Human Rights
- Reprieve
- Road2DC
- The Sanctuary
- Torture Survivors Coalition
- Witness Against Torture
- Vet Voice

*LIBERAL DOSES OF HUMOR*

- Dudehisattva (Dood Abides)
- Dunce Upon a Time~Socially Awkward, Sexually Incompetent: The BC Woods Blog
- Pancake City
- The Rude Pundit
- Violent Acres-Like You, But With Poor Impulse Control


The Wild Wild Left Home

The Web The Wild Wild Left


Creative Commons License
This work by http://thewildwildleft.soapblox.net/ is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.
Powered by: SoapBlox